Epilepsy and seizure information for healthcare professionals

Innovation Center

 

Back to top

 

About Epilepsy & Seizures

This section contains information about epilepsy syndromes and seizure classifications, as well as the psychiatric and behavioral aspects of epilepsy. Also discussed is the relationship between hormones and epilepsy, including reproductive function and catamenial epilepsy.

For additional information, many of the topics in this section offer further readings and references and each page features a glossary feature to elaborate on epilepsy-related terms.

Topics in This Section

arrow Classifying Seizures
arrow Overview of Epilepsy Syndromes
arrow Neonatal Epileptic Seizures and Syndromes
arrow Idiopathic Epileptic Seizures and Syndromes in Infancy
arrow Epileptic Encephalopathies in Infancy and Childhood
arrow Severe Neocortical Epileptic Syndromes in Infancy and Childhood
arrow Benign Childhood Focal Seizures
arrow Idiopathic Generalized Epilepsies
arrow Familial (autosomal dominant) Focal Epilepsies
arrow Symptomatic and Probably Symptomatic Focal Epilepsies
arrow Idiopathic Generalized Epilepsies
arrow Reflex Seizures and Related Epileptic Syndromes
arrow Hormones and Epilepsy
arrow Psychiatric and Behavioral Aspects

Classifying Seizures
Author: Gregory L. Holmes, MD

How are seizures classified?

One of the first priorities facing the physician when evaluating a patient with epileptic seizures is to determine seizure type and, when possible, epileptic syndrome. This determination is critical because seizure type and epileptic syndrome to a great extent determine the type of evaluation the patient will receive, as well as the type of therapy.

Seizures are classified into two basic groups, partial and generalized (see list below).

Partial seizures involve only a portion of the brain at the onset. They can be further divided into two types:

  • simple partial, in which consciousness is not impaired
  • complex partial, in which consciousness is impaired

Both types of partial seizures can spread, resulting in secondarily generalized tonic-clonic seizures.

Generalized seizures are those in which the first clinical changes indicate that both hemispheres are initially involved. Consciousness usually is impaired during generalized seizures, although some seizures, such as the myoclonic type, may be so brief that impairment of consciousness cannot be assessed.

International Classification of Epileptic Seizures1

I. Partial seizures
A. Simple partial seizures
1. With motor signs
a. Focal motor without march
b. Focal motor with march (Jacksonian)
c. Versive
d. Postural
e. Phonatory
2. With somatosensory or special-sensory symptoms
a. Somatosensory
b. Visual
c. Auditory
d. Olfactory
e. Gustatory
f. Vertiginous
3. With autonomic symptoms or signs
4. With psychic symptoms
a. Dysphasia
b. Dysmnesic
c. Cognitive
d. Affective
e. Illusions
f. Structured hallucinations
B. Complex partial seizures
1. Simple partial seizures at onset, followed by impairment of consciousness
a. With simple partial features
b. With automatisms
2. With impairment of consciousness at onset
a. With impairment of consciousness only
b. With automatisms
C. Partial seizures evolving to secondarily generalized seizures
1. Simple partial seizures evolving to generalized seizures
2. Complex partial seizures evolving to generalized seizures
3. Simple partial seizures evolving to complex partial seizures evolving to generalized seizures
II. Generalized seizures
A. Absence seizures
1. Typical absence seizures
a. Impairment of consciousness only
b. With mild clonic components
c. With atonic components
d. With tonic components
e. With automatisms
f. With autonomic components
2. Atypical absence seizures
B. Myoclonic seizures
C. Clonic seizures
D. Tonic seizures
E. Tonic-clonic seizures
F. Atonic seizures

Topics in This Section

arrow Distinguishing Factors
arrow Generalized Seizures
arrow Nonepileptic Seizures
arrow References
arrow Status Epilepticus

Adapted from: Holmes GL. Classification of seizures and the epilepsies. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 1-36.
With permission from Elsevier (www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised January 2004 by Gregory L. Holmes, MD, Dartmouth Medical School

Distinguishing factors
Author: Gregory L. Holmes, MD

How can the physician distinguish between simple partial seizures and complex partial seizures?

In most cases, the two basic types of partial seizures are easy to differentiate.

Simple partial seizures

The signs or symptoms of simple partial seizures depend on the location of the seizure focus. Seizures involving the motor cortex usually are not difficult to diagnose. They commonly consist of rhythmic or semi-rhythmic clonic activity of the face, arm, or leg.

Seizures with somatosensory, autonomic, and psychic symptoms (hallucinations, illusions, déja vu) may be more difficult to diagnose. Psychic symptoms more often are a component of a complex partial seizure.

Complex partial seizures

Complex partial seizures (CPS) are one of the most common seizure types encountered in both children and adults.

By definition, all patients with CPS have impaired consciousness. The patient either does not respond to commands or responds in an abnormally slow manner. Simple staring and impaired responsiveness alone may characterize a CPS, but usually behavior during the seizure is more complex. Automatisms (involuntary motor activity) are common during the period of impaired consciousness. This behavior is quite variable. Common activities include:

  • facial grimacing
  • gesturing
  • chewing
  • lip smacking
  • snapping fingers
  • repeating phrases

The patient does not recall this activity after the seizure.

The length of CPS varies. They usually last from 30 seconds to several minutes. Their length helps to differentiate them from absence seizures, which usually last less than 15 seconds.

Most patients have some degree of postictal impairment, such as tiredness or confusion, after CPS.

Complex partial seizures may be preceded by a simple partial seizure (aura), which can serve as a warning to the patient of a more severe seizure to come. The nature of the aura may enable the physician to determine the cortical area in which the seizure is beginning.

Adapted from: Holmes GL. Classification of seizures and the epilepsies. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 1-36.
With permission from Elsevier (
www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised January 2004 by Gregory L. Holmes, MD, Dartmouth Medical School

 

Back to top

 

Generalized seizures
Author: Gregory L. Holmes, MD

What are the types of generalized seizures?

Primary generalized seizures arise simultaneously in both cerebral hemispheres. They generally involve impairment of consciousness, but their manifestations can range from barely noticeable to a tonic-clonic convulsion.

Sometimes it is difficult to distinguish primary generalized seizures from secondarily generalized seizures that are preceded by a very brief simple partial seizure, especially since the patient may have no memory of it.

Types of generalized seizures include:

Absence
Myoclonic
Clonic
Tonic
Tonic-clonic
Atonic

Adapted from: Holmes GL. Classification of seizures and the epilepsies. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 1-36.
With permission from Elsevier (www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised January 2004 by Gregory L. Holmes, MD, Dartmouth Medical School

Absence
Author: Gregory L. Holmes, MD

The revised International Classification of Epileptic Seizures categorizes absence seizures as generalized seizures, indicating bihemispheric initial involvement both clinically and electroencephalographically.2 Many children with absence seizures (formerly known as "petit mal") can be further categorized as having a characteristic epileptic syndrome.

Types of absence seizures

The terms typical and atypical absence seizures were used by the International Classification of Epileptic Seizures to describe and categorize the various absence types.

Typical absence seizures

The simple typical absence consists of the sudden onset of impaired consciousness, usually associated with a blank facial appearance without other motor or behavioral phenomena. This subtype is actually relatively rare. It comprised only 9% of 374 absence seizures video-recorded from 48 patients by Penry and associates.3

The complex typical absence is accompanied by other motor, behavioral, or autonomic phenomena:

Motor phenomena:

Clonic components may be quite subtle. They most frequently consist of eye blinking. Clonic activity may range from nystagmus to rapid jerking of the arms. Changes in tone often include a tonic postural contraction leading to flexion or hypertonic extension. Although a decrease in tone rarely causes a fall, it may lead to nodding of the head or the dropping of objects.

Behavioral phenomena:

Automatisms are the commonest clinical accompaniment, occurring in 44% of 476 typical absence seizures studied by simultaneous video-EEG radiotelemetry in 27 patients.4 Automatisms are semipurposeful behaviors of which the patient is unaware. The patient cannot recall them afterwards. There are two types:

Autonomic phenomena:

Autonomic phenomena associated with absence seizures may include:

Neither the autonomic changes nor automatisms allow one to distinguish absence from other seizure types.

Atypical absence seizures

Atypical absence seizures have traditionally been characterized4,5 as having:

Comparison of typical and atypical absence seizures

Holmes et al5 compared 426 typical and 500 atypical absence seizures in 54 children. The atypical absence seizure lasted significantly longer, on average, than the typical absence seizure. The most common initial clinical manifestation in either type was a change in facial expression or appearance of a blank stare. A pause or slowing of motor activity was also frequently noted as the initial finding in both types. The atypical absences were significantly more likely to have diminished postural tone or tonic or myoclonic activity as the initial clinical feature.

A blank stare or change in facial expression was the sole clinical finding in only 16% of typical and 28% of atypical absences. Automatisms, eye blinking, and lip smacking occurred more commonly in typical absences. These automatisms were usually perseverative, often consisting of playing with a toy or game. De novo automatisms were associated with longer spells and most commonly consisted of rubbing the face or hands or smiling.

A change in postural tone (either an increase or a decrease) was more commonly seen in atypical absences.

Both typical and atypical absences shared many characteristics:

Although statistically significant differences can be identified, there is considerable overlap between the two seizure types. They most likely represent a clinical continuum. This overlap also pertains to the electroencephalogram (EEG) and proposed pathophysiology.

Typical absence seizures

The EEG signature of a typical absence seizure is the sudden onset of 3-Hz generalized symmetrical spike-and-wave or multiple spike-and-slow wave complexes. (See EEG.) The voltage of the discharges is often maximal in the frontocentral regions. The frequency tends to be faster (about 4 Hz) at the onset and slower (down to 2 Hz) toward the end of discharges if they persist longer than 10 seconds. The spike-and-wave discharge may be precipitated by hyperventilation or photic stimulation.

Absence Seizure EEG

Ictal EEG of typical absence seizure of childhood absence epilepsy:
Note the regular rhythm of the discharge, the constant spike and slow wave relation, and the abrupt onset. The opening phase is often variable and unreliable. The child remains unresponsive from the onset of the initial phase to the onset of the terminal phase of the discharge. However, she is able to understand the technologist during the terminal phase, when the ictal discharge is waning.

The interictal EEG background is often normal in typical absence seizures. Using the preceding ictal EEG criteria to classify absence seizures, Holmes et al.4 found that only 44% of 27 patients with typical absences had normal EEG backgrounds, however. Diffuse slowing was seen in 22% and paroxysmal spikes or sharp waves in 37%.

The discharges are more numerous during all sleep states except rapid eye movement (REM) sleep. During sleep the bursts are briefer and irregular, slowing to 1.5 to 2.5 Hz.

Hyperventilation, photic stimulation, and hypoglycemia will activate typical absence seizures. Hyperventilation is the most effective procedure.

Clinical effects generally can be seen when discharges last longer than 3 seconds. Detailed neuropsychologic investigations have demonstrated functional impairment from a spike-and-wave burst of any duration.6 Auditory reaction times were delayed 56% of the time when a stimulus was presented at the onset of the EEG paroxysm and were abnormal 80% of the time when the stimulus was delayed 0.5 second. Responsiveness may improve as the paroxysm continues.

Atypical absence seizures

In atypical absence seizures the ictal EEG is more heterogeneous, showing 1.5- to 2.5-Hz slow spike-and-wave or multiple spike-and-wave discharges, which may be irregular or asymmetric (See EEG.).

Atypical Seizure EEG

Slow spike-and-wave activity in a patient with atypical absence seizures.

The interictal EEG background is generally abnormal. In the study of Holmes et al,4 only 11% of 27 patients with atypical absences had a normal interictal EEG. Diffuse slowing and focal or multifocal spikes or sharp waves were seen in 85%.

Adapted from: Holmes GL. Classification of seizures and the epilepsies. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 1-36.
With permission from Elsevier (www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised January 2004 by Gregory L. Holmes, MD, Dartmouth Medical School

 

Back to top

 

Myoclonic
Author: Gregory L. Holmes, MD

Myoclonic seizures are characterized by sudden, brief (<350 milliseconds), shock-like contractions.

The contractions may be:

  • generalized
  • confined to the face and trunk
  • confined to one or more extremities
  • confined to individual muscles or groups of muscles.

Any group of muscles can be involved in the jerk. Myoclonic seizures may be dramatic, causing the patient to fall to the ground, or be quite subtle, resembling tremors. Because of the brevity of the seizures, it is not possible to determine if consciousness is impaired.

Myoclonus may occur as a component of an absence seizure or at the beginning of a generalized tonic-clonic seizure.

Electromyography shows short bursts of synchronized activity, often involving simultaneous activation of agonist and antagonist muscles. The contractions of the muscles are quicker than the contractions with clonic seizures.

On EEG, myoclonic seizures are usually associated with generalized spike-and-wave activity.

Adapted from: Holmes GL. Classification of seizures and the epilepsies. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 1-36.
With permission from Elsevier (www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised January 2004 by Gregory L. Holmes, MD, Dartmouth Medical School

 

Back to top

 

Clonic
Author: Gregory L. Holmes, MD

Clonic seizures are similar to generalized tonic-clonic seizures but consist only of rhythmic or semi-rhythmic contractions of a group of muscles. (That is, there is no tonic phase.) These jerks can involve any muscle group. The arms, neck, and facial muscles are most commonly involved.

Clonic seizures are much more common in children than adults.

Adapted from: Holmes GL. Classification of seizures and the epilepsies. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 1-36.
With permission from Elsevier (www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised January 2004 by Gregory L. Holmes, MD, Dartmouth Medical School

 

Back to top

 

Tonic
Author: Gregory L. Holmes, MD

Tonic seizures are brief seizures (usually <60 seconds) consisting of the sudden onset of increased tone in the extensor muscles.7-9 If standing, the patient typically falls to the ground. These seizures are invariably longer than myoclonic seizures. Occasionally tonic seizures terminate with a clonic phase.

The degree to which consciousness is impaired is often difficult to assess. In seizures lasting longer than a few seconds, impairment of consciousness is usually apparent.

Postictal impairment with confusion, tiredness, and headache is common. The degree of postictal impairment is usually related to the duration of the seizure.

Electromyographic activity is dramatically increased in tonic seizures.

Tonic seizures are frequently seen in patients with the Lennox-Gastaut syndrome, a disorder consisting of mixed seizure types, mental retardation, and the EEG findings of a slow spike-and-wave pattern.10-12 Seizures are usually more frequent at night.

Types of tonic seizures

Tonic seizures have been divided into four types:

Other categorizations

In a study of epileptic falls in children, Ikeno et al13 described two types of tonic seizures:

  1. The tonic type is characterized by excessive flexion or extension of fingers, forced flexion of hand joints, jaw protrusion, shoulder elevation, upper arm abduction, and tonic flexion of the trunk. This hypertonic state continues unchanged even after the patient falls down.


  2. Flexor spasms have a different distribution of hypertonicity. The head is flexed forward, the shoulders are elevated, the arms are flung outward and forward, and the thighs are flexed at the hip. Unlike the tonic seizure type, fingers, hand joints, and elbows remain neither tonic nor atonic. Flexor spasms may resemble infantile spasms.

Egli et al7 described tonic seizures that lead to falls as “axial spasms.” Reflecting a uniform pattern of movement, these seizures consist of moderate flexion of the hips, upper trunk, and head lasting from 0.5 to 0.8 second. The arms are almost always abducted, elevated, and in a semiflexed position. The fall is provoked by the rapidity and violence of the flexion in the hips.

Electroencephalography

Ictal manifestations of tonic seizures usually consist of bilateral synchronous spikes of 10 to 25 Hz, of medium to high voltage, with a frontal accentuation. Simple flattening or desynchronization also may occur. Occasional multiple spike-and-wave or diffuse slow activity may occur during a tonic seizure (See EEG).

Multiple spike-and-wave activity in a patient with tonic seizures.

Adapted from: Holmes GL. Classification of seizures and the epilepsies. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 1-36.
With permission from Elsevier (www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised January 2004 by Gregory L. Holmes, MD, Dartmouth Medical School

 

Back to top

 

Tonic-clonic
Author: Gregory L. Holmes, MD

Generalized tonic-clonic seizures

Generalized tonic-clonic (GTC) seizures (formerly called grand mal seizures) usually are not difficult to diagnose. The loss of consciousness usually occurs simultaneously with the onset of a generalized stiffening of flexor or extensor muscles (the tonic phase). After the tonic phase, generalized jerking of the muscles (clonic activity) occurs. A GTC seizure is almost always followed by deep postictal sleep.

Some patients may have a simple partial seizure (aura) preceding the loss of consciousness. This indicates that the onset of the seizure is located in a limited area. As the seizure spreads in the cortex, the seizure develops into a GTC seizure. This type of seizure is classified as a simple partial seizure with secondary generalization.

Two types of episodes that may end with brief generalized tonic-clonic seizures should not be treated with antiepileptic drugs:

  • breath-holding attacks in toddlers
  • syncope in both children and adults

Adapted from: Holmes GL. Classification of seizures and the epilepsies. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 1-36.
With permission from Elsevier (
www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised January 2004 by Gregory L. Holmes, MD, Dartmouth Medical School

 

Back to top

 

Atonic
Author: Gregory L. Holmes, MD

Atonic (astatic) seizures, or drop attacks, are characterized by a sudden loss of muscle tone. They begin suddenly and without warning. There may be total lack of tone, so that the person will fall quickly to the floor and cannot protect himself or herself against injury. Consciousness is impaired during the fall, although the patient may regain alertness immediately upon striking the floor.

Some atonic seizures may be fragmentary and lead to dropping of the head with slackening of the jaw or dropping of a limb.

Electromyographic activity is lost during atonic seizures.

Atonic seizures are rare and are usually confined to childhood.9,13,14 Most children with drop attacks also have myoclonic or tonic seizures.13 Most of these children have the Lennox-Gastaut syndrome.

Atonic attacks are often associated with myoclonic jerks either before, during, or after the atonic seizure.14,15 This combination has been described as myoclonic-astatic seizures.

Electroencephalography

Atonic seizures are usually associated with rhythmic spike-and-wave complexes varying from slow (1 to 2 Hz) to more rapid, irregular spike- or multiple spike-and-wave activity.

Adapted from: Holmes GL. Classification of seizures and the epilepsies. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 1-36.
With permission from Elsevier (www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised January 2004 by Gregory L. Holmes, MD, Dartmouth Medical School

 

Back to top

 

 

Back to top

 

Nonepileptic seizures
Author: AJ Rowan

What are nonepileptic seizures?

Nonepileptic seizures (NESs) are episodic paroxysmal events that resemble epileptic seizures in many respects. Such events are often difficult, if not impossible, to differentiate from events due to epilepsy, and misdiagnosis leads to inappropriate treatment with antiepileptic drugs (AEDs).

To arrive at an accurate diagnosis, the clinician first must differentiate between the two major types of NESs:

  • Psychogenic NESs are symptoms of an underlying psychiatric disorder, without a physiologic basis.
  • Physiologic NESs are caused by physiologic dysfunction, such as cardiac arrhythmias, hypotensive episodes, or cerebrovascular disease. Such conditions may result in loss of consciousness, with or without associated motor manifestations. A detailed history and appropriate investigations (e.g., Holter monitoring, noninvasive carotid artery studies, or tilt-table testing) will usually reveal the true diagnosis.

Most of the discussion in this part of epilepsy.com pertains to psychogenic NESs.

Why is an understanding of nonepileptic seizures important?

NESs are relatively common. As many as 20% of the population seen in specialized seizure clinics may suffer from NESs. Put another way, about 50,000 persons in the United States have NESs.

NESs may remain undiagnosed for years. If the patient has a past history of epilepsy and experiences a recurrence of seizures or currently has epileptic seizures and a new seizure type develops, the true diagnosis may be obscured. The clinician usually does not witness the seizures and must rely on information provided by the patient, an outside observer, or both.

Mistakenly attributing NESs to epilepsy generally leads to futile treatment with AEDs. Continuing seizures in spite of increasing AED dosage or multiple AEDs is frustrating for patient and physician alike. Moreover, AED therapy may lead to toxic side effects, causing additional disability and frustration. A correct diagnosis will lead to appropriate psychiatric intervention, discontinuation of AED therapy, and improvement in the patient's quality of life.

Adapted from: Rowan AJ. Diagnosis and management of nonepileptic seizures. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 173-184.
With permission from Elsevier (
www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed February 2004 by Orrin Devinsky, MD, New York University

Causes
Author: AJ Rowan

What are the most common psychiatric diagnoses associated with nonepileptic seizures?

Nonepileptic seizures are classified as a conversion disorder in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV). Conversion disorder is included in the broader category of somatoform disorders. Essentially, the patient presents with symptoms suggestive of a neurologic or other general medical condition, preceded by conflicts or other stressors. The symptom is not feigned, and appropriate investigations fail to reveal evidence of a causative organic condition. The symptoms cause significant distress and interfere with the patient's general functioning.

In some patients, NESs are part of a symptom complex subsumed under the rubric somatization disorder. In this condition, the patient has a pattern of recurring multiple and significant somatic complaints beginning under the age of 30 and extending for a prolonged period, sometimes many years.

Patients with NESs also suffer from associated psychiatric disorders. More than one condition is often present. Anxiety disorders are commonly encountered, often unrecognized by patient or physician. In particular, many patients fulfill DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for panic disorder, with or without agoraphobia. The symptom complex of NESs may be due solely to panic attacks, or the attacks may coexist with NESs. Careful inquiry is essential in order to establish the diagnosis.

Depression is often seen in patients with NESs. In some, it has been proposed that the pain of depression has been unrecognized or unaddressed by family or others. As a result, the development of NESs may constitute a mechanism of bringing the patient's problems to the attention of the medical profession.

Psychotic disorders such as schizophrenia are considered uncommon accompaniments of NESs, although they may be seen.

Other conditions that are even less common include malingering and factitious disorder.

A detailed psychiatric interview will usually bring out any associated psychiatric disorders. In some cases, however, application of the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV (SCID) may be required to determine the number and extent of the patient's problems.

Adapted from: Rowan AJ. Diagnosis and management of nonepileptic seizures. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 173-184.
With permission from Elsevier (
www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised February 2004 by Orrin Devinsky, MD, New York University

 

Back to top

 

Diagnosis

Numerous studies have evaluated the clinical differentiation between nonepileptic seizures (NESs) and epileptic seizures. This section addresses the evaluation, diagnosis and treatment of NESs, and provides a guide for discussing the diagnosis of NES with patients.

Clues from the history
Author: AJ Rowan

Generally, there are many differences between the histories of patients with nonepileptic seizures (NESs) and those of patients with epilepsy.

NESs may occur only in the presence of others or, conversely, may never have been observed. In the latter case the clinician is dependent on the patient's description, which may be fragmentary and incomplete. Indeed, only loss of consciousness may be reported. If such a patient has a history of epilepsy, the probability of misdiagnosis is high.

The interview may reveal a clear emotional trigger for NESs. This criterion is not at all definitive, however, because patients with epilepsy often ascribe seizures to "stress."

The patient's reaction to his or her seizures may offer clues to the diagnosis. The demeanor of the patient with NESs classically has been described as la belle indifference, but many authors have found such indifference to be atypical. More commonly, the patient is quite concerned about the seizures, sometimes excessively so. In fact, an exaggerated emotional response may provide a clue to NESs but should be considered in context with other information.

Treatment with AEDs, regardless of types or combinations, is rarely successful, although transient responses are not uncommon. In fact, increasing doses of AEDs may lead to a paradoxical increase in seizure frequency. Patients with NESs sometimes complain of intolerable side effects at low doses or slow dose escalation of AEDs.

A history of physical or sexual abuse is common in patients with NESs. At an appropriate time the clinician should inquire into this sensitive subject. Drawing firm conclusions from a history of abuse is perilous, however, because abuse is common in people with epilepsy and in the general population. Many people with epilepsy also have poignant histories of childhood or marital abuse.

Finally, suspicion is sometimes kindled by the patient's previous experience with other people who have epilepsy. The person may have encountered seizures in a professional capacity-for example, in a hospital setting. A family member or friend may have seizures, or the patient's own previous or current epileptic seizures may serve as templates for NESs. In addition, cultural influences may play a role in some cases.

Do patients with nonepileptic seizures have a typical psychologic profile?

Patients with NESs have no characteristic psychologic profile. Perhaps the most consistent results have resulted from the application of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI). In particular, Dodrill has reported that MMPI profiles differ between patients with epilepsy and those with NESs (Dodrill 1993). The typical findings in many NES patients are relatively high scores on the hysteria and hypochondriasis scales, with a lower score on the depression scale. These characteristics differentiated NESs from epilepsy in about 80% of cases.

Thus, the MMPI offers useful information but cannot be said to have sufficient power for diagnostic certainty. The results of psychologic testing, therefore, must be taken in concert with the results of other testing and considered supportive or nonsupportive of the diagnosis of NES.

Adapted from: Rowan AJ. Diagnosis and management of nonepileptic seizures. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 173-184.
With permission from Elsevier (
www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed February 2004 by Orrin Devinsky, MD, New York University

 

Back to top

 

Clues from the event
Author: AJ Rowan

If the clinician observes one or more NESs, the phenomenology of the event may raise suspicion that the patient does not have epilepsy. Nothing in the clinical expression of NESs can be considered definitively pathognomonic, however. Only by recording the behavioral and electrographic characteristics can the event be diagnosed confidently.

One common clue is that NESs often have a gradual onset, but epileptic seizures typically start and end suddenly. For example, a simple absence seizure (formerly known as petit mal) begins with sudden loss of awareness, which continues for several seconds and then ends abruptly, at which time the person is fully aware and functional. Similarly, a tonic-clonic epileptic seizure begins suddenly with a fall, loss of consciousness, and frequently a cry. Motor activity continues for a minute or so, progressing predictably and ending abruptly. At that point the patient is deeply comatose and flaccid. With NESs, on the other hand, consciousness may be preserved during the peri-ictal phase.

In contrast, a nonepileptic seizure characterized by vigorous motor activity frequently builds in intensity as the event progresses. The event itself is often of longer duration than its epileptic counterpart, sometimes lasting many minutes or even hours. Moreover, the motor movements may have a waxing and waning quality through the course of the seizure. (Some NESs with motor manifestations are characterized by vigorous motor activity and intervening periods of quiet unresponsiveness.) The event tends to subside gradually, and the postictal state-whether unresponsiveness or apparent confusion-is less profound than in the case of a tonic-clonic convulsion.

Although it is often said that tongue biting and incontinence do not occur with NESs, some patients with documented NESs have reported these symptoms. Bladder and bowel incontinence and self-injury are rare but can occur. When biting occurs, it tends to involve the tongue tip, arms, or other body areas more than the sides of the tongue.

NESs that resemble true absence attacks are more difficult to differentiate from epilepsy than motor events. The staring, unresponsive state provides no obvious clues concerning the nature of the attack. However, if such attacks are of long duration, one might suspect that the diagnosis is other than epilepsy. The only way to confirm the true diagnosis is to record the event in question by EEG monitoring, preferably with simultaneous video monitoring.

Patients with NESs resembling complex partial seizures also present diagnostic difficulties, owing to the protean manifestations of the epileptic events. Such patients may exhibit confusional states with or without apparent automatic activities. Again, recording of the event is essential to confirm the diagnosis.

Another feature suggestive of NESs is an emotional response during or after an event. Crying and other emotional vocalizations are common. Although crying occurs in rare patients with epilepsy, it is more frequent in those with NES.

Typical NESs, especially motor events, do not seem to follow a "physiologic" progression. The motor activity tends to be chaotic, sometimes with flinging movements. Alternation of the movements, opisthotonus, pelvic thrusting, and dystonic posturing may be present. One important distinguishing feature of NESs is that, in contrast to epileptic seizures, the face is often not involved.

Some patients with NES exhibit avoidance behavior during events, especially during quiescent phases. For example, if the patient's arm is held aloft and released, the patient may avoid striking himself or herself in the face. Such behavior suggests that the attack is nonepileptic.

In some cases NESs can be initiated and ended by suggestion and verbal intervention.

What is the diagnostic role of prolactin levels?

Elevations in serum prolactin occur in the postictal phase (20 to 25 minutes after the seizure subsides) after some types of epileptic seizures. The most consistent increase is found after generalized tonic-clonic convulsions.

NESs do not usually raise prolactin levels, although this observation has been disputed. Thus, prolactin levels can be useful in some cases of NES, but they cannot be considered diagnostic. (See more about postictal prolactin testing.)

What epileptic seizures are most likely to be mistaken for NESs?

Frontal lobe seizures

Seizures originating in the frontal lobe, including the supplementary motor area, present a major diagnostic dilemma in differentiating NES from epilepsy. Frontal lobe seizures may be characterized by prominent, chaotic, apparently "nonphysiologic" motor activity, such as flailing, alternating repetitive movements of the extremities, "bicycling" movements of the lower extremities, and tonic posturing. To most observers, such a picture appears to be clearly psychogenic or "hysterical." Moreover, the patient retains a degree of awareness during this stage. After the event subsides, there is little or no confusion. These factors appear to confirm that the event was not epileptic.

Frontal seizures often include a brief phase of tonic posturing that precedes the chaotic motor phase. This phase may take the form of abduction of the upper extremities or unilateral posturing with deviation of head and eyes. Forced downward deviation of the eyes has been observed. There may be accompanying vocalization. During this phase the patient is unresponsive, and the transition to the chaotic motor phase is rapid and abrupt. Inasmuch as the initial phase is frequently unobserved whereas the prominent motor activity commands attention, the suspicion that the event may be epileptic is correspondingly diminished.

Seizures with pelvic thrusting movements

Pelvic thrusting movements are often regarded as a sign of NESs, but such movements can be seen in epileptic seizures, either during tonic-clonic convulsions or with complex partial seizures. Pelvic movements in tonic-clonic convulsions are more likely to be retropulsive, however, whereas those associated with NESs are usually propulsive.

Seizures with gradual onset and cessation

The features of gradual onset and gradual cessation, suggestive of NESs, may be present in varying degrees in generalized convulsions or complex partial seizures. The "gradual" aspect of epileptic seizures is more apparent than real; the electrographic seizure begins abruptly, but the clinical expression may seem gradual.

Prolonged or intermittent seizures

The duration of generalized tonic-clonic convulsions and complex partial seizures is usually under 2 minutes, but either seizure type may be prolonged. In addition, the seizures may appear to be intermittent, such as in complex partial status epilepticus or in serial motor seizures.

Clues from the response to treatment

NESs and epilepsy frequently coexist in the same patient. The best available data suggest that in 20% of NES cases there is either a past history of epilepsy or coexisting epileptic seizures (Ramsay 1993).

The presence of both conditions complicates both diagnosis and management. Because the physician usually does not observe the event and it is difficult for most people to describe sudden or rapidly evolving events, a presumptive diagnosis of epilepsy is likely. Changes in therapy probably will be based on a seizure record that contains both epileptic seizures and NESs. Increases in the dosage of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) will follow reports of continuing seizures, even though the true problem may be superimposed NESs.

If AED dosage increases do not alter the seizure frequency or if seizures appear to increase with increased doses, the possibility of NESs or coexisting epilepsy and NESs should be considered.

Tapering AEDs, on the other hand, may exacerbate epileptic seizures but should not change the frequency of NESs.

Adapted from: Rowan AJ. Diagnosis and management of nonepileptic seizures. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 173-184.
With permission from Elsevier (www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised February 2004 by Orrin Devinsky, MD, New York University

 

Back to top

 

Video-EEG monitoring
Author: AJ Rowan

The "gold standard" in the diagnosis of nonepileptic seizures (NESs) is a recording of a typical event during video-EEG monitoring. This procedure is available at all centers specializing in epilepsy and is increasingly available at general hospitals and even in some neurologic group practices.

During this procedure, the EEG is recorded for a prolonged period, accompanied by continuous closed-circuit video observation. The digitized EEG and recorded behavior are displayed simultaneously, allowing point-to-point correlations of recorded events and any accompanying electrographic changes.

Types of monitoring

Two types of monitoring are in general use:

  • an outpatient procedure with a duration of 6 to 8 hours (Daytime Monitoring, or DAYMON)
  • inpatient monitoring, which continues for 24 hours or more

Outpatient studies are less expensive and more convenient than inpatient monitoring. DAYMON is most appropriate for patients with relatively high seizure frequencies-at least three events per week. To increase yield, DAYMON should be carried out when the patient is sleep-deprived.

If the patient's seizure frequency is relatively low, inpatient video-EEG monitoring for 24 hours or more is indicated. This procedure requires hospital admission and a dedicated staff. Although more costly than DAYMON, inpatient monitoring is effective. More than one event may be recorded, increasing diagnostic certainty if the events are stereotyped. Inpatient monitoring also allows recording of a full night's sleep, increasing the possibility of recording sleep-provoked epileptiform activity as well as nocturnal clinical events. Several days of monitoring may be required before the diagnosis is made.

Video-EEG monitoring procedures

During video-EEG monitoring, the patient wears an EEG transmitter connected to a wall outlet by coaxial cable. Wall-mounted video cameras provide continuous behavioral observation. Both EEG and video signals are transmitted to a control room, where the EEG is reformatted and conducted to a video monitor. The EEG signal and video are displayed simultaneously for on-line observation, and both are recorded on videotape. The EEG may be recorded on paper or stored on optical disc.

The patient can move about and carry out normal activities, such as napping, talking, and watching television. Participation by a family member or friend is encouraged, especially someone who has observed the patient's events in the past. Hyperventilation and photic stimulation are carried out. These may cause clinical or diagnostic changes in patients with epileptic seizures but not NESs. Although NESs may occur spontaneously, the application of these procedures appears to increase diagnostic yield.

An important diagnostic aid is suggestion techniques to precipitate one of the patient's usual events. These techniques may take the form of placing alcohol pads over the carotid arteries or administering intravenous saline. The patient is told that the procedure will be carried out to induce a seizure and that only by recording an event will a diagnosis be possible. If an event is precipitated and the event is typical of the patient's usual seizure, a diagnosis of NESs is highly likely. False positives are rare. When DAYMON is performed in this manner, an overall success rate of approximately 60% may be expected (French 1993). There are some ethical concerns about the use of deception, although definitive diagnosis can allow patients to obtain proper therapy and avoid unnecessary antiepileptic drugs, with their side effects.

Video-EEG findings

During NESs, the EEG will show:

  • no epileptiform activity
  • no initial change such as premonitory spikes
  • no postseizure slowing

Although the EEG tracing is frequently obscured by movement artifact, small interpretable segments containing alpha activity may be apparent, indicating that consciousness is preserved.

A normal or nonepileptiform EEG during a seizure may suggest a NES, but it can also occur during a simple partial seizure or frontal lobe complex partial seizure undetected by surface leads. A normal EEG during a seizure in which the patient is displaying generalized motor movements would not be expected in a true epileptic seizure, however.

The most important task is to ensure that the recorded event(s) are typical of the patient's spontaneous attacks. This task can be accomplished only by reviewing the recorded attack with a person who has witnessed such events. If it is determined that the recorded and spontaneous attacks are similar, a presumptive diagnosis of NESs can be made.

Some clinicians require that more than one attack be recorded, but this is not always possible. Nonetheless, it appears that a single recorded event similar to previous attacks is sufficient to consider NESs the most likely diagnosis.

This diagnosis, of course, does not exclude the possibility of coexisting epilepsy, especially if the patient has attacks with different clinical features. Some epilepsy patients experience psychogenic nonepileptic seizures at some point, and patients with psychogenic nonepileptic seizures can have neurologic illness.

The interictal EEG is not useful in making the distinction because it may be normal or abnormal in either case. The interictal EEG of patients with NESs may contain epileptiform discharges, even though the ictal record does not reveal electrographic seizure activity.

Alternatives to intensive video-EEG monitoring

If intensive video-EEG monitoring is not available, a diagnosis of NESs can be made with reasonable assurance using commonly available tools. Probably the best method is to obtain an EEG after the patient is sleep-deprived. A video camera can be set up in the EEG room. During the recording, and after explaining the procedure, apply techniques of suggestion, emphasizing the importance to the patient of recording an event.

The use of 24-hour ambulatory cassette EEG recording to diagnose NESs is not recommended unless a home video unit is available. Unless the behavioral aspects of the attack are recorded, there is too little diagnostic information. Moreover, excessive EEG artifacts during an attack often makes it very difficult to interpret the cassette EEG. If the patient has attacks characterized by staring with little motor activity, a cassette EEG can be useful. Certainly, differentiation of absence seizures from NESs characterized by loss of awareness is relatively easy. Again, simultaneous video recording greatly enhances diagnostic power.

Adapted from: Rowan AJ. Diagnosis and management of nonepileptic seizures. In: Schachter SC, Schomer DL, eds. The comprehensive evaluation and treatment of epilepsy. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1997. p. 173-184.
With permission from Elsevier (
www.elsevier.com)

Reviewed and revised February 2004 by Orrin Devinsky, MD, New York University

 

Back to top

 

 

Back to top

 

Talking to the patient
Author: AJ Rowan

Telling the patient about nonepileptic seizures

When the diagnosis of nonepileptic seizures (NESs) is confirmed, it must be presented in a positive, supportive, and nonthreatening manner. The physician must have an empathetic, compassionate attitude to ensure the patient's allegiance and offer hope for the future.

NESs should be described as a disorder that cannot be treated with anticonvulsant medication. Emphasize the disability associated with NESs and discuss the effect of the attacks on the patient's life. Also stress that NESs have psychosocial consequences as profound as those of epilepsy but point out that t